Skip to main content

Unsolicited Advice, Judgments and Opinions.

“There is no good reason for a retail company and an office company to be housed within the same company.” I read this proclamation in last Wednesday’s Wall Street Journal.  It was made by one Alexander Goldfarb, an analyst with the firm Sandler O'Neil and was prompted by the $18 billion market cap real estate company Vornado's decision to possibly spin off its strip center retail real estate portfolio, which would leave it with primarily office assets. I thought to myself:  Who is Alexander Goldfarb?  What are his credentials?  How does he know what’s best for Vornado?  More important, his comment struck a deep chord inside of me as I’ve noted how our society is so quick to pass judgment on others, or to give unsolicited advice, me included I’m embarrassed to say.


With a bit of research I discovered that Mr. Goldfarb joined Lehman Brothers after his schooling where he became a REIT analyst.  For those of you readers who may not know, that means that he mostly sat in an office, looked at financial statements of publicly traded real estate companies, and tried to determine which were good and which were not.  Since leaving Lehman he has performed the same functions at UBS and now at Sandler.  All told, Mr. Goldfarb has analyzed REIT’s for 11 years.  It seems that he’s never actually bought a piece of real estate, financed one, managed one or leased one.  And yet, he feels comfortable speaking with such certainty and, perhaps even more absurd, he somehow feels comfortable passing judgment on one of the real estate’s true legends.  Maybe worst of all, in this upside down world we live in, his opinion is given enough credence to move investors to either buy or sell shares of stock.

Steve Roth is the Chairman and CEO of Vornado.  Mr. Roth began his career acquiring and operating properties in 1964 and founded the company now known as Vornado.  Until 1997 when Vornado acquired 4 million square feet of office properties through its purchase of the Mendik Company, Vornado’s experience, as well as Mr. Roth’s was predominantly in the area of retail properties, and in particular strip centers - the very same asset that Mr. Goldfarb is suggesting that Vornado should not own.  Is anybody getting the joke yet?  Mr. Roth is a self-made billionaire, by the way, with much of his worth invested in Vornado stock.

Now, as I juxtapose these two very different backgrounds I ask myself: “Who’s judgment would I trust in doing what is best for Vornado, Mr. Roth’s or Mr. Goldfarb’s?”

I’m not really writing this to pick on Mr. Goldfarb, who is probably reasonably competent (but probably not always), or REIT analysts (who also can be competent at times but should probably have more actual hands-on real estate experience).  My point is that we are all too quick to impart our opinions and to offer advice to others, often unsolicited.  I have been as guilty as anyone, and maybe (much) more than most.  It is one of the negative qualities that I’ve continued to work on personally to overcome.  When my kids call me “Mr. Know-it-all” it hurts, and is my reminder that I need to re-double my efforts.

There is a very famous speech given by Teddy Roosevelt that is often referred to as “The man in the arena.”  This speech is brilliant, and whenever I read it I am deeply moved.  I won’t reprint it here, but I would say that everyone ought to know this speech.  It is among my couple of favorite collection of words, and I am sure everyone will find it inspiring and on point.  Basically, the message is to do more and criticize less.

Popular posts from this blog

Taxes and Hyperbole

There is a new tax code in the U.S., and this is indeed a “Yuuuge” deal. As far as I can tell, it is as close to an unmitigated home run for America as can be. Is it perfect? Of course, it’s not. The code retains its unwieldy size and complexity, largely as a result of compromises made in order to bribe congressmen and senators for their votes. Until we get term limits, it seems we’re stuck with a tax code that is big and complex. However, it does hit the mark on a few key issues: most every taxpayer will now pay less to the federal government (except those in states with ridiculously mismanaged economies who now will be forced to hold their state politicians more accountable); and our businesses, large and small alike, will remit less of their profits to the federal government and will be liberated to invest that savings into growth – which will surely create job and wage growth in the productive private sector.

You Need to Ask the Right Question

If you ask the wrong questions, the answers will probably also always be wrong, and even irrelevant.  This might seem obvious, but I’ve noticed that this truth is often completely overlooked, and even by the world’s most intelligent. While I’m certain this is so in every facet of life, for the purpose of this short paper I will focus on the investment/finance world.

We, The Deplorables

I recently saw a German movie called “Look Who’s Back” on Netflix, which I strongly recommend.  The film fictionally chronicles the return of Adolf Hitler to modern-day Germany and does a tremendous job of illustrating how Hitler’s call to arms for a better Germany for Germans resonates with the average German in the film. It cannot be lost on anyone who views this film that the message repeatedly heard from these average Germans that “what he says is mostly true…” is a frightening one, and one that is easy to imagine not only Germans saying but French, British, and Americans too.