Skip to main content

Trusting Authority

As I’ve written in the past, I have the privilege of teaching a business school class at USC.  I’ve got a significant portion of my students who have come to the school from China, which has added a fascinating dimension to the classroom as they bring their own unique perspective that enriches the experience for all.


As I was reading and grading homework this week, I noticed that there seemed to be a consistent trend among my Chinese students to trust government.  The assignment involved explaining the connection between macroeconomics and real estate, and analyzing that relationship as it exists today.  In many, if not most of the submissions from my Chinese students there was a consensus that the U.S. economy is surging.  They pointed to the Q3 GDP of 3.5%, the greatly reduced unemployment levels, and the Fed’s decision to curtail quantitative easing as affirmation that things are sunny for the U.S. economy.  In complete contrast, many, if not most of my non-Chinese students were less optimistic, and pointed to the large percentage of underemployed or those who had abandoned the job market, as well as the imbalanced impact of the past 6 years of monetary policy which seemed in their view to have enriched the already rich and have done little good for the great majority of Americans.

As I read these homework submissions and observed this trend it got me thinking about the cultural proclivities towards things like trusting authority, and what that meant for nations.  I initially concluded that given the central planning structure of Chinese government and its history of limited freedom it should not be surprising that the notion of accepting government proclamations at face value is the norm.  Yet, as I thought some more, I wondered if it was possible that the Chinese students are deeply skeptical of their own nation’s government but view the U.S. government as being highly trustworthy.  I will ask the students this week in class.  Either way, this seems to be a noteworthy and significant difference between the American culture and the Chinese and I would bet that it will likely have broad impact both in each nation’s future as well as how the two nations relate to one another.

Popular posts from this blog

Taxes and Hyperbole

There is a new tax code in the U.S., and this is indeed a “Yuuuge” deal. As far as I can tell, it is as close to an unmitigated home run for America as can be. Is it perfect? Of course, it’s not. The code retains its unwieldy size and complexity, largely as a result of compromises made in order to bribe congressmen and senators for their votes. Until we get term limits, it seems we’re stuck with a tax code that is big and complex. However, it does hit the mark on a few key issues: most every taxpayer will now pay less to the federal government (except those in states with ridiculously mismanaged economies who now will be forced to hold their state politicians more accountable); and our businesses, large and small alike, will remit less of their profits to the federal government and will be liberated to invest that savings into growth – which will surely create job and wage growth in the productive private sector.

You Need to Ask the Right Question

If you ask the wrong questions, the answers will probably also always be wrong, and even irrelevant.  This might seem obvious, but I’ve noticed that this truth is often completely overlooked, and even by the world’s most intelligent. While I’m certain this is so in every facet of life, for the purpose of this short paper I will focus on the investment/finance world.

We, The Deplorables

I recently saw a German movie called “Look Who’s Back” on Netflix, which I strongly recommend.  The film fictionally chronicles the return of Adolf Hitler to modern-day Germany and does a tremendous job of illustrating how Hitler’s call to arms for a better Germany for Germans resonates with the average German in the film. It cannot be lost on anyone who views this film that the message repeatedly heard from these average Germans that “what he says is mostly true…” is a frightening one, and one that is easy to imagine not only Germans saying but French, British, and Americans too.